CompareTaux

Articles · Mortgage

The offer arrives by mail with a date on it. It is not the market rate.

What a renewal offer actually contains, why it is what it is, and the one thing to do before signing.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

The renewal offer that arrives by mail is designed to keep you as a client, not to reflect what the market offers. At renewal, changing lenders generally carries no penalty: getting a point of comparison before the deadline is the one step that turns a signature into a negotiation.

What the offer really contains

The envelope arrives a few weeks or months before your term matures. It holds a renewal proposal, a deadline to reply and, often, a form ready to sign. The whole package looks official, simple and without alternatives.

What it contains is very specific: a product type, a term length, a payment schedule and conditions. What it leaves out is just as specific: no comparison with what other lenders are offering the same day, and no mention that you are free to decline.

This offer is a starting point, not a verdict. It reflects what your lender is willing to grant when it assumes you will sign without looking elsewhere. That nuance changes how to read it: not as "what the market offers", but as "what my lender offers a client who does not compare".

The first step is therefore to read it in full, with your current contract beside it, rather than filing it in a drawer until the last week.

Why it is what it is

A retention offer is priced on a probability: the likelihood that the client signs as is. Lenders know that a large share of borrowers simply carry their loan forward without comparing. The offer is therefore calibrated for that behaviour, not for a client who shops around.

This is neither dishonest nor illegal. It is simply the logic of a price set in the absence of competition. Any business does the same when the customer is captive: it has no reason to improve an offer nobody challenges.

The practical consequence is this. If you sign without a point of comparison, you have no way of knowing whether the offer is reasonable, high or exceptional. You are negotiating against yourself, or rather not negotiating at all.

Conversely, once you hold one or two comparable proposals, the conversation changes. Your current lender may adjust its terms, hold its offer or let you go. In each case you will have decided knowingly, which is precisely the goal.

Why the window matters

At renewal, the penalty for changing lenders is generally nil, because the contract is reaching its end. It is the only point in the cycle when you can leave without paying to break an agreement in progress. It is also, precisely, when the offer arrives.

Mid-term, the picture is very different: prepayment penalties can be significant and the way they are calculated varies by loan type and lender. Looking at your loan from another angle then means paying that penalty, which discourages most borrowers.

The renewal window is therefore an opportunity not to waste. It is also short: the offer carries a deadline, and changing lenders takes time (appraisal, file review, notary).

Check your contract for the exact maturity date, and ask your lender from when an offer can be accepted or declined. Some take requests very early, others only in the weeks before maturity. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada publishes neutral information on mortgage renewal.

What nobody asks you

The renewal form asks a single question: will you sign? It asks nothing that might make your loan evolve.

No one asks whether your term still suits your situation. Perhaps your income has changed, your family has grown or a move is on the horizon. A term chosen several years ago may no longer match your plans.

No one asks whether you could accelerate your payments. A more frequent schedule or a slightly higher payment can reduce the principal faster, but that depends on your privileges and your budget.

No one asks whether you will need cash within the year: renovations, debt consolidation, a life project. Renewal is often the simplest moment to raise it, because no penalty is added.

Finally, no one checks that your prepayment privileges are adequate. Those privileges determine how much you can repay beyond your regular payments, at no charge, during the term. It is up to you to ask these questions, or to have an authorised person ask them for you.

Reading the whole offer, not just one number

Comparing an offer is not looking at a single line. The same rate can hide very different conditions, and an offer that looks less attractive may prove more flexible in use.

Here is what to examine in the offer you received, and in any comparable proposal:

  • the product type (fixed, variable, open or closed) and the term length;
  • prepayment privileges and extra-payment options;
  • how the penalty would be calculated if you had to break the contract later;
  • whether the loan can be ported or moved to another property if you relocate;
  • fees, future renewal conditions and any insurance requirements.

Get into the habit of asking everyone the same thing: what is included, what is charged on top, and what happens if my plans change mid-term? Written answers are worth more than verbal promises.

A more flexible offer can carry a different cost from a rigid one. What matters is that the comparison covers equivalent products under the same assumptions, otherwise it loses its meaning.

A hypothetical scenario

Imagine a person we will call Nadia. Her mortgage is approaching maturity and a letter from her lender proposes a renewal, with a deadline to reply. The letter is clear and polite, and nothing in it suggests that another route exists.

Nadia first rereads her contract and notes the exact maturity date. She sees that no penalty applies on that date. She then writes a short list: a possible job change within the year, a potential need for cash for renovations, and the wish not to be caught off guard by rising payments.

With that list, she asks an authorised person to obtain comparable proposals. She reads each offer in full, looking at privileges, fees and conditions rather than a single figure. She then goes back to her current lender to ask whether it can adjust its offer.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no result. It illustrates an approach: know your date, name your needs, compare complete offers, then decide. In this example she could stay, leave or renegotiate; the decision is entirely hers.

Mistakes to avoid

Certain mistakes come up again and again at renewal. Knowing them lets you avoid them without special effort.

  • Signing and returning the mailed offer without comparing, simply because it is there and looks official.
  • Waiting until the last week, which cuts your negotiating room and the time available to obtain other proposals.
  • Looking at one number only and forgetting privileges, fees, the penalty calculation and portability.
  • Not mentioning an upcoming project (a move, a renovation, a purchase) that could make the contract a poor fit.
  • Carrying forward the same term and amortization without asking whether they still suit you.
  • Confusing comparing with switching: comparing also helps you negotiate with your current lender, and staying may well be the right decision.

None of these mistakes is serious on its own, but they add up. A conversation with an authorised person registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) helps spot them in your file before the deadline.

A good way to avoid them is to turn this list into calendar reminders, set well before maturity, so that time works for you rather than against you.

Questions to ask before signing

Here is a checklist to keep handy, to adapt to your contract. It applies to your current lender as much as to anyone presenting you with a proposal.

Before the deadline:

  • What is the exact maturity date, and from when can I accept an offer?
  • What penalty would apply if I left, and on what date does it become nil?
  • What transfer, appraisal or notary fees would be added if I change lenders?
  • Which prepayment privileges and extra-payment options are included?
  • How would a future penalty be calculated?
  • Is the loan portable if I move?

For your own needs:

  • What cash might I need before the next maturity?
  • Do my term and amortization still make sense?

Note each answer, preferably in writing, and keep the documents. If an explanation stays unclear, ask for it to be rephrased: that clarity is already part of the comparison.

How CompareTaux can help

CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no rates, makes no automated decisions and sells no products. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you.

That person can review your contract, obtain proposals from several lenders, explain the differences between them and answer your questions. It is the person, not the website, who can give advice suited to your situation.

You are under no obligation to follow through. If you prefer to stay with your current lender, the exercise will at least have let you sign knowingly. And if you want to check a professional, the AMF register is public.

To go further on your own, the public bodies listed below offer independent, free and up-to-date information. The AMF and the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada can also help you verify a specific point, such as how to confirm someone is registered or what a contract term means.

Whatever you decide, keep the paper trail: the offer, your contract, the proposals you gathered and the written answers you received. If you later need to explain a choice, or revisit it at the next maturity, that folder saves time and spares you from starting from scratch. It also makes any future conversation with an authorised person quicker and more precise.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to accept a renewal offer?

No. It is a proposal from your lender, which you can accept, negotiate or decline before the deadline. Read it in full, compare it with other proposals and ask in writing for any clarification you need before signing.

Is there a penalty if I change lenders at renewal?

Generally not, since the term is reaching maturity. Transfer, appraisal or notary fees may still apply depending on your situation. Check your contract and ask your lender and the person assisting you for the details in writing.

When should I start comparing?

As soon as you know the maturity date, ideally several months ahead. Some lenders accept requests early, others only closer to the date. Ask from when an offer can be accepted so you can plan your steps.

Can I negotiate with my current lender?

Yes, and it is common. The mailed offer is a starting point. If you hold comparable proposals, you can present them and ask whether it can adjust its terms. Nothing guarantees it will, but the conversation is legitimate.

Does comparing mean I have to switch lenders?

No. Comparing helps you decide knowingly. You may well conclude that staying with your current lender, perhaps with adjusted terms, is the right call. What matters is that it is a choice rather than a reflex.

What does CompareTaux do in this process?

CompareTaux forwards your request to an authorised person registered with the AMF. The site displays no rates and makes no decisions. The person can obtain proposals, explain them and apply the rules to your situation.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.