Your landlord’s insurance covers the building, not your belongings or the damage you might cause. A tenant policy generally covers your property, your civil liability and your relocation costs. The civil liability limit is the figure to watch.
A common and costly misunderstanding
Many tenants think their landlord’s insurance covers them, at least in part. It is one of the most widespread misunderstandings in home insurance, and one of the costliest when a loss occurs.
The reasoning is understandable: the building is insured, you live in it, so you are protected. But an insurance policy protects a specific person and a specific interest. The landlord insures what belongs to them, that is, the building. They do not insure your furniture, your clothing, your devices, nor the liability you might incur toward them or toward your neighbours.
This article displays no premiums and does not say which policy to choose. It explains what a tenant policy really covers, why liability toward the building is the main issue, and which items to check before signing or renewing.
An authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can then examine your precise situation: type of unit, lease, roommates, valuables. The aim here is to give you the right questions to ask.
The misunderstanding: two policies that do not overlap
The owner insures the building, because it belongs to them. They do not insure your furniture, nor damage you might cause. Two policies coexist and do not overlap: the landlord’s protects the building, the tenant’s protects their property and their liability.
Concretely, if a fire destroys your belongings, the landlord’s insurance reimburses none of them. It serves to rebuild the building. If you have no tenant policy, you bear alone the loss of your things and of your temporary housing.
Some leases or landlord letters mention the obligation, or the recommendation, to take out tenant insurance. Even without such a clause, the logic remains the same.
To clarify your situation:
- ask your landlord what their policy covers, and what it does not;
- reread your lease for any mention of insurance;
- make a rough inventory of what you would lose in a loss.
This small exercise makes the misunderstanding visible, which is already half the way there. Many tenants discover, at this stage, that nobody ever told them the two policies were separate, and that the landlord assumed they knew.
The real exposure: your liability toward the building
People think first of their belongings, but the heaviest risk for a tenant is their liability. A fire starting in your unit or a water loss can damage the building and neighbouring units. If your fault is established, the sums at stake far exceed the value of your personal property.
Under Quebec law, a tenant can be held responsible for damage caused to the building by their own fault or by that of people they answer for, such as family members or guests. The precise rules depend on the circumstances and are best explained by reliable legal sources such as Éducaloi, or a notary.
And liability is not limited to fire. A forgotten pot, an overflowing dishwasher, a bathtub left running, a faulty appliance: these ordinary situations can cause significant damage to the neighbours below and to the landlord.
In such cases the landlord’s insurer may, depending on the circumstances, seek to recover from the tenant what it has paid. The civil liability coverage in your own policy is precisely what responds to that situation.
What a tenant policy covers
A tenant policy generally includes three blocks of protection, which are worth telling apart.
Your property: furniture, clothing, appliances, electronics, personal items. Depending on the policy, they are reimbursed at replacement cost or at depreciated value, a distinction worth understanding before you sign.
Your civil liability: it responds to damage you might cause to others or to the building, with a limit that applies to each event. It is the most important block when a loss affects the building.
Your relocation costs: if the unit becomes uninhabitable following a covered loss, the policy may reimburse extra housing and living costs for the period provided. That last item is the one people forget and the one that gets used soonest, because an uninhabitable home forces you to find somewhere else to stay the very next day.
To check in each block: the limits, the exclusions, the deductible, valuables that need an endorsement (jewellery, sports equipment, professional equipment) and special conditions such as having roommates or short-term rentals.
The figure to watch: the civil liability limit
Of all the amounts in a tenant policy, only one is likely to be exceeded by a single event: the civil liability limit. Personal property has a limited value, which you can estimate. Liability depends on the scale of the damage caused to others.
Moving up a tier usually costs little compared with the protection gap it closes. That is one reason this limit deserves particular attention when you buy or renew.
To see clearly:
- find the civil liability limit on your declarations page;
- ask what it applies to (injury to people, third-party property, the building);
- ask whether higher tiers are offered and whether a complementary coverage exists;
- check whether liability also covers members of your household and damage caused by a guest.
No figure is recommended here: the right level depends on your building, your lifestyle and your tolerance for risk. An authorised person can discuss it with you based on your situation.
A hypothetical scenario
Picture a tenant, whom we will call Léa, moving into a unit in a multi-unit building. She sees that the landlord has insurance and concludes she has nothing to add.
A friend, a tenant for longer, asks whether she has checked what that policy covers. Léa asks her landlord, who replies that the insurance protects the building, nothing else. She then understands that her furniture, her clothing and her liability are covered by no one.
She takes the time to draw up a rough inventory, reread her lease and ask an authorised person what a tenant policy includes. She asks precise questions: the liability limit, relocation costs, the deductible, valuables.
Depending on the answers, she decides whether the proposed policy meets her needs and whether she wants a higher liability tier.
This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: clarify who insures what, make an inventory, ask precise questions, then decide with an authorised person.
Mistakes to avoid
A few mistakes come up often among tenants. Knowing them helps you avoid them without special effort.
- Believing the landlord’s insurance covers your belongings or your liability.
- Not taking out a tenant policy because “I don’t own much”.
- Underestimating the real value of your belongings, which add up faster than you think.
- Ignoring the civil liability limit or choosing it without understanding its purpose.
- Forgetting relocation costs, which are among the most frequently used.
- Not declaring a roommate, a home-based business or a short-term rental.
- Not updating the policy after a move, a major purchase or a change in circumstances.
- Letting the policy renew without rereading it, when coverage and deductibles may change.
None of these mistakes is rare. They come from the fact that tenant insurance is a low-visibility contract, bought quickly and rarely reread. A conversation with an authorised person, registered with the AMF, helps spot them.
A good habit is to reread the policy once a year and update it whenever your situation changes. A new roommate, a home office, an expensive purchase or a move to a different building can each change what the policy should say, and the insurer can only adjust what it has been told.
Questions to ask and a checklist
Here is a list to go through with your landlord, then with an authorised person.
For the landlord:
- what exactly does your insurance cover?
- does my lease require me to take out insurance?
- are there special rules on the use of certain appliances or water?
For the insurer or authorised person:
- what is the civil liability limit, and what does it apply to?
- can I raise that limit, and how?
- are my belongings reimbursed at replacement cost or depreciated value?
- what relocation costs are covered, and for how long?
- what is the deductible, and does it vary by coverage?
- do my valuables need an endorsement?
- how does the policy treat a roommate or a guest?
For yourself:
- do I have an up-to-date inventory of my belongings?
- have I kept photos or receipts for important items?
Write down the answers and keep them with your lease. If a problem arises later, being able to show what was asked and what was answered makes any discussion with the insurer or the landlord simpler. Photograph your belongings room by room once a year; it takes minutes and makes an inventory far easier to rebuild.
How CompareTaux can help
CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no premiums, makes no automated decision and sells no product. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you.
That person can explain what a tenant policy includes, discuss the civil liability limit and relocation costs, and present options if that makes sense. It is the person, not the website, who can give advice tailored to your situation.
You are under no obligation to follow through. If, after checking, you conclude that your situation is already covered, the process will have let you know it knowingly. And if you want to check a professional, the AMF register is public.
To dig deeper on your own, the AMF explains the rights of insurance consumers, Éducaloi popularises the rules of law that apply to tenants, and Option consommateurs offers independent information.
Frequently asked questions
Does my landlord’s insurance protect me in part?
Generally not. It covers the building and the landlord’s interest, not your belongings or your personal liability. Ask in writing what it covers exactly, and check whether your lease requires the tenant to carry insurance.
Why is civil liability so important?
Because a loss starting in your unit, such as a fire or a water leak, can damage the building and neighbouring units. If your fault is established, the sums at stake far exceed the value of your personal property. This coverage responds to that risk.
What are relocation costs?
They are extra housing and living costs the policy may reimburse if your unit becomes uninhabitable following a covered loss. Limits on duration and amount vary. Ask your insurer about them before signing.
Are my roommates covered by my policy?
Not necessarily. Many policies cover household members but treat roommate arrangements differently, sometimes requiring each roommate to hold their own policy. Tell your insurer about the situation and ask what applies.
Can I raise my civil liability limit?
Often yes, through a higher tier or a complementary coverage, depending on the insurer. Ask what options exist and how they apply. The right level depends on your building and situation, and an authorised person can discuss it with you.
Will CompareTaux tell me which policy to choose?
No. CompareTaux displays no premiums, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation and present options.
Sources
No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.