CompareTaux

Guides · Disability insurance

The waiting period you choose is the share of risk you keep.

How the elimination period affects the premium, how to choose it against your cash reserves, and why it interacts with your other coverage.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

The elimination period is the time between the start of a disability and the first payment. The longer it is, the lower the premium, but the longer you must rely on your own funds. An AMF-authorised person can tailor it to your situation.

What it is, in practice

The elimination period, also called the waiting period, is the time that passes between the onset of your disability and the moment your contract starts paying benefits. During that time no benefit is paid: you live on your savings, your sick leave, or other coverage.

It can be compared to the deductible on home insurance, but expressed in time rather than money. You agree to carry the start of the risk yourself, and in exchange the contract costs less to keep.

It helps to separate this period from neighbouring ideas. The elimination period is not the benefit period, meaning the maximum length of time the insurer may pay, and it is not the waiting period of another plan, public or group, which follows its own rules. Each contract has its own definition, and how the period is counted (calendar days, consecutive days, continuous disability) is written in the contract wording.

Keep the central idea in mind: the period you choose is the share of risk you keep. It is a financial planning choice as much as an insurance choice.

The effect on the premium

The longer the period, the lower the premium, and the difference is substantial. Insurers know why: most work absences are short, and a longer period removes the most frequent claims from the contract.

Lengthening the period is therefore the most effective lever for making coverage affordable without cutting the monthly amount insured. For many people it is a more sensible trade-off than lowering the amount covered: the contract still protects the same level of income, but only after a stretch where you manage on your own.

This lever has a limit, though. A very long period lowers the premium, but it lengthens the time your household must absorb the loss of income alone. If your reserves run out before the first payment, the saving on the premium will have been of no use.

CompareTaux displays no premiums and does not put a number on this effect: the gap depends on your age, your occupation, your health and the insurer. An authorised person can obtain proposals with different periods and present them side by side, using the same assumptions.

How to choose your period

The starting point is a very concrete exercise: count the cash you actually have available and how long you could hold out with no income. The period should match that span, not the lowest figure on offer.

To do the exercise honestly:

  • add up what is genuinely accessible quickly (emergency savings, non-registered accounts), leaving out anything costly or impossible to withdraw;
  • estimate your essential monthly expenses: housing, food, insurance, debts, childcare;
  • subtract the income that would continue (spouse, another job, investment income);
  • divide your reserves by the monthly shortfall: that gives a length of time you could hold out, to be read with caution.

Think also about sources of income replacement that may cover part of the period: employer sick days, short-term group coverage, certain public benefits depending on the cause of the absence.

If the margin is thin, a shorter period costs more but protects your budget better. If your reserves are solid, a longer period can be reasonable. The right answer depends on you, and it is a point to discuss with an authorised person.

Coordinating with group coverage

If your employer provides short-term disability, your individual contract’s period can be aligned with the end of that benefit, avoiding paying twice for the same window.

The idea is simple: the short-term group plan covers the first months, and the individual contract takes over afterwards. The individual elimination period is then set to match the end of the employer’s protection. You do not pay a high premium for a gap that is already covered elsewhere.

This strategy rests on one condition, however: that the employer’s protection is really in place when you need it. The group plan belongs to the employer. It can be amended, moved to another insurer or ended, and it generally stops when you leave the company.

Before aligning your period with the group plan, check:

  • the exact length of the short-term benefit, in your group insurance booklet;
  • its start and end conditions, and how it coordinates with public plans;
  • what would happen to your protection if you changed jobs or lost yours.

Payment arrives afterwards

Benefits are generally paid in arrears: a ninety-day period often means a first payment around the fourth month. That is one month later than most people expect.

Why the lag? Because the insurer generally pays after confirming the period of disability, not before. First comes the elimination period itself, then the time to process the file: forms to complete, the treating physician’s report, an assessment, sometimes documents about your income. All of it can add weeks.

The real calendar therefore looks more like this:

  • the onset of disability, which starts the count;
  • notice to the insurer, to be given promptly within the time set by the contract;
  • the end of the elimination period;
  • processing of the claim and, if accepted, the first payment, often at the end of one of the insurer’s pay cycles.

None of these steps is unusual, but they belong in your planning. A household that expects the first cheque the day after the period ends risks an unpleasant surprise. Add a cushion of cash to the period you choose, and notify the insurer early rather than late.

A hypothetical scenario

Picture a self-employed worker, whom we will call Léa. She earns her living alone, has no group plan and worries about what would happen if she could no longer work. A first quote looks expensive with a short period.

She then does the exercise described above. She finds that her emergency savings would let her hold out a few months, that her spouse keeps earning an income, but that rent and the household’s fixed costs would remain heavy. She also knows no employer will pay her sick days.

She asks an authorised person for two or three proposals that are identical except for the period. Reading them, she notices that the saving on the premium is real, but that the longest period exceeds what her reserves can absorb without stress. She picks an intermediate period and keeps a cushion for the delay before the first payment.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: start from your cash rather than the price, compare versions of the same contract, then decide. In a different situation, Léa’s conclusion could have been quite different.

Mistakes to avoid

Several mistakes come up often when choosing an elimination period.

  • Choosing the longest period to get the lowest premium, without checking that your reserves can carry you through it.
  • Forgetting the payment lag: the first payment arrives after the period ends, not during it.
  • Relying on employer group protection without checking its length or what happens if the job ends.
  • Padding your “cash” with money that is locked in, hard or costly to withdraw when needed.
  • Failing to revisit the period when life changes: a birth, a home purchase, a new job, depleted savings.
  • Comparing premiums without comparing the definitions of disability, the benefit period and the exclusions, which matter as much as the waiting period.
  • Neglecting to notify the insurer: late notice can complicate the opening of a claim.

None of these mistakes is beyond repair, but they are easier to fix before signing than after. An authorised person, registered with the AMF, can spot these points in your file and help you choose a period that fits the rest of your protection.

Questions to ask an authorised person

Here is a list to bring to the meeting, to adapt to your situation.

  • Which elimination periods does this contract allow, and how is the period counted (calendar days, continuous disability, cumulated periods)?
  • If I go back to work for a few days and then relapse, does the count start over?
  • How long after the end of the period is the first payment usually issued?
  • How does this contract coordinate with my group plan and with public plans?
  • What happens if my group plan ends or I change jobs?
  • Can you show me the same coverage with several periods, side by side?
  • Can the period be adjusted later, and on what conditions?
  • What evidence must I provide, and within what time must disability be reported?

Ask for the answers in writing when you can. A clear, documented explanation is already part of the comparison between two proposals.

If a point stays vague, do not hesitate to ask for it to be rephrased. The authorised person is there so that you understand what you sign, and you can always check their registration in the AMF’s public register.

How CompareTaux can help

CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no premiums, makes no automated decision and sells no product. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you.

That person can take stock of what you already have (group plan, public plans, savings), present proposals with different elimination periods and explain what each choice changes. It is the person, not the website, who can give advice tailored to your situation.

You are under no obligation to follow through. If, after the discussion, you prefer to keep your current protection or change nothing, the process will at least have let you decide with full knowledge.

To dig deeper on your own, the public resources listed below offer independent information: the AMF to verify a registration and learn about your rights, the FCAC for general reference points, the Ombudsman for Life and Health Insurance in case of a dispute, and Option consommateurs for practical advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is a longer elimination period always better?

No. A longer period generally lowers the premium, but it lengthens the time you must live on your own means. It should be measured against your real cash reserves, not only the price. An authorised person can compare several versions of the same contract with you.

Does the period start on the date I stop working?

Generally it starts on the date the disability begins under the contract’s definition, often confirmed by a physician. The precise rules, especially for relapses or partial returns, are written in the contract. Read that section before signing and ask for clarification.

What if I go back to work and then relapse?

It depends on the contract’s relapse clause. Some contracts add together periods that are close in time, others restart the period. This point should be checked precisely, since it can change a great deal in practice. Ask for the answer in writing.

Can I change my elimination period after buying?

Sometimes, but it is not guaranteed. Lengthening it, which lowers the insurer’s risk, is generally easier than shortening it, which may require a new assessment of your health. Find out about this option before concluding the contract.

Is my group plan enough to cover the period?

Perhaps for part of it, depending on its length and conditions, but it belongs to your employer, who can change or end it. It generally stops with the job. Take stock of what you actually have before building your protection.

Will CompareTaux recommend a period for me?

No. CompareTaux displays no premiums, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation, your reserves and your other coverage before presenting options.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.