A prepayment penalty is calculated by one of two methods: three months’ interest or an interest rate differential. Which one applies depends on your contract, and the gap can be considerable. Ask for the detailed calculation in writing before committing elsewhere.
Why a penalty exists
When a lender grants you a mortgage for a given term, it funds itself for that same period, counting on the interest it expects to receive from you. If you repay before maturity, that calculation is broken, and the contract provides compensation for the shortfall.
So it is not a sanction, nor a punishment for changing your mind: it is a clause you signed, often years earlier, and it was already written in your contract. The trouble is that few people reread it until they need it.
The penalty generally applies only mid-term. At maturity, when the contract reaches its end, you are free to renew, switch lenders or repay, usually without a penalty. That is why the maturity date is worth noting down as soon as you sign.
This article explains the two main calculation methods, what makes the result differ from one lender to another, and how to do the arithmetic before deciding to break a mortgage. It contains no rate and no dollar figure: only your agreement, or an authorised person who reviews it, can give you a number.
Method one: three months’ interest
This is the easiest method to grasp. Take your loan balance, multiply it by the interest rate in your contract, then divide the result by four. The amount you get is three months’ interest.
This method generally applies to variable-rate mortgages. It also applies to fixed-rate ones when the interest rate differential calculation, covered below, produces a smaller amount. In many contracts, the lender in fact takes the higher of the two results: three months’ interest on one side, the differential on the other.
The advantage of this method is that it is predictable. You can estimate the order of magnitude yourself, using the balance and the rate on your annual statement. You only need to confirm with the lender the exact balance on the repayment date and the rate actually used.
For most people it is the more forgiving method. But it is not always the one that applies: the wording of your contract decides, not intuition. Reread the prepayment clause, which sets out the formula used, and have it explained if a sentence seems ambiguous.
Method two: the interest rate differential
The second method compares your contract rate with the rate the lender could get today by lending the same sum for the time left in your term. If the gap favours the lender, meaning rates have fallen since you signed, it charges you that gap applied to your balance and to the remaining period.
When rates have fallen, this figure far exceeds three months’ interest. It can even run into thousands of dollars on a mid-sized mortgage, and the longer the remaining term, the wider the gap grows. Conversely, if rates have risen since you signed, the differential is small or nil, and the three-month method prevails.
That is why the same person can pay very little one day and a great deal another, on a nearly identical loan. The cost depends on when you break the contract as much as on the contract itself.
The exact formula (which comparison rate, which period, what floor) is specific to each lender. Do not try to guess it: ask for the written breakdown, then have an authorised person check the result if the amount is significant.
The role of the posted rate
Many lenders do not compute the differential from the rate they would actually grant today, but from their posted rates, the ones on their public grid. And they factor in the discount you received when you signed, deducting it from the comparison rate.
The outcome is surprising. Two lenders, same balance, same contract rate, same remaining period: the penalties can differ twofold. The difference does not come from your file, but from how each lender worded its formula.
What to keep in mind:
- the posted rate is not the granted rate, and the gap between them counts in the calculation;
- the discount you obtained at signing can turn against you on the way out;
- the formula is in the contract, but in terms that are sometimes hard to read;
- a careful reading before signing costs far less than a surprise at the moment of leaving.
This is one reason why comparing two offers is never just comparing two rates. For each offer, also ask how the penalty would be calculated, and if possible for a numerical example using fictional assumptions.
What avoids or reduces it
Several mechanisms can avoid or reduce the penalty, provided you think of them before breaking the mortgage rather than after.
A portability clause lets you carry the mortgage to a new property if you move. The contract is not broken, so no penalty is due. The lender must still approve the new file: the clause is not an automatic right.
In some cases, a buyer can assume your mortgage, on the lender’s terms. Prepayment privileges, for their part, let you cut the balance without a penalty within the limits set in the contract, which shrinks the base on which a penalty would be calculated if you later had to break the loan.
Some mortgages also allow a penalty-free payout on specific terms, for instance when the repayment is funded by the same lender or on a particular date in the term.
None of these mechanisms is universal. Each depends on your contract, your lender and your situation. List them from your agreement, then discuss them with the lender or with an authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), who can apply them to your case.
Ask for it in writing
You are entitled to a detailed calculation of the penalty, with the method used and the figures behind it: balance, rate, remaining period, comparison rate. A bare amount given over the phone is not enough to decide.
Demand this calculation before signing anything elsewhere. A misjudged penalty alone can wipe out the expected gain from refinancing, and it is much harder to back out once a new commitment has been made.
A few useful precautions:
- ask how long the amount remains valid, because it moves with rates and with the balance;
- ask whether administrative or discharge fees are added to the penalty;
- ask for a calculation at several dates if you hesitate on timing;
- keep the written reply with your other mortgage documents.
If the amount seems high or hard to understand, you can ask an authorised person to go over it with you. If you are not satisfied with the explanation, public resources such as those of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) explain your rights and recourse in a neutral way.
Before breaking, do the arithmetic
The decision to break a mortgage is made with figures, not with an impression. You have to weigh, on one side, the penalty and the costs of the transaction and, on the other, the expected gain over the remaining term.
The costs to include go beyond the penalty. Depending on the case, appraisal fees, notary fees, discharge fees and sometimes file-closing fees may be added. The gain, for its part, has to be estimated honestly: it depends on the real difference between your current situation and the one you would obtain, over the period it will apply.
You should also ask whether the reason for breaking is lasting. A one-off need for cash, a separation, a move, a debt consolidation: each case has its own solutions, and breaking the mortgage is not always the cheapest.
A broker or an authorised person can run this calculation up front, using your documents. This is exactly the kind of decision where instinct misleads: a small rate gap is tempting, while a penalty of several thousand dollars can absorb the gain for years.
A hypothetical scenario
Picture a person we will call Hélène. She has a fixed-rate mortgage whose maturity is still far off. She hears that rates have moved and wonders whether she should refinance.
Before doing anything, she rereads the prepayment clause and finds that her contract calls for the higher of two amounts. She asks her lender in writing for a detailed calculation, valid for a specific date, with the method and the figures used.
She then consults an authorised person, handing over that calculation, her contract and her plans for the next few years. Together they compare the penalty and the transaction costs with the possible gain over the remaining term. They also look at another route: waiting for maturity, or using her prepayment privileges to cut the balance in the meantime.
This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: read, ask for the written calculation, compare cost and gain, then decide. In this example the decision is Hélène’s, made with verifiable figures rather than an impression.
Mistakes to avoid
A few mistakes come up often when people consider breaking a mortgage. Knowing them helps you avoid the costliest.
- Estimating the penalty from memory or with a simple online calculator, without asking for the lender’s official calculation.
- Assuming the three-month method applies, when the contract may use the rate differential.
- Committing to a new lender before knowing the exact penalty.
- Forgetting the fees that come on top: appraisal, notary, discharge, administration.
- Overlooking alternatives: portability, assumption by a buyer, prepayment privileges, waiting for maturity.
- Looking only at the immediate monthly gain, without relating it to the remaining term.
- Not seeking the view of an authorised person when the amount at stake is significant.
None of these mistakes is rare, and each can be costly. A written calculation, a careful reading of the contract and a conversation with a person registered with the AMF are enough to avoid most of them.
Questions to ask
Here is a list of questions to put to your lender, then to an authorised person, before deciding anything.
- Which calculation method applies to my contract, and under which wording?
- What is the exact amount today, and until what date is it valid?
- Which comparison rate do you use, and do you factor in the discount I received?
- What fees come on top of the penalty: discharge, administration, appraisal?
- Is my mortgage portable? On what conditions, and within what time frame?
- Could a buyer assume my mortgage?
- Which prepayment privileges do I have left this year, and how do they reduce the penalty?
- What would happen if I waited for maturity rather than breaking now?
Note the answers and ask for them in writing. CompareTaux displays no rates and makes no decision for you: the service routes your request to an authorised person, who can review your contract and explain the options. The resources of the AMF and the FCAC can also help you validate a specific point.
Frequently asked questions
Does the penalty apply at the maturity of my term?
Generally not. At maturity the contract reaches its end, and you can renew, switch lenders or repay without a penalty. It mainly targets prepayments made mid-term. Check the exact date and terms in your contract, and confirm them with your lender.
How do I know which calculation method applies to me?
It is set out in the prepayment clause of your mortgage contract. Variable-rate loans often follow the three-month method, while fixed-rate ones sometimes use the higher of the two amounts. If needed, ask your lender to explain it in writing.
Can I estimate the penalty myself?
You can get an order of magnitude from the balance and the rate, especially for the three-month method. For the differential, the formula and comparison rates are specific to each lender. Only the lender’s written calculation is reliable enough to decide on.
Does a move force me to pay the penalty?
Not necessarily. If your mortgage is portable, you can carry it to the new property without breaking the contract, subject to the lender’s approval. In some cases a buyer can also assume the loan. Check these clauses before you sell.
Do prepayment privileges reduce the penalty?
Indirectly. They let you cut the balance without a penalty, within the contract’s limits, which shrinks the base on which a future penalty would be calculated. They do not remove the penalty, and using them must respect the dates and caps provided.
Can CompareTaux tell me whether to break my mortgage?
No. CompareTaux displays no rates, calculates no penalty and recommends nothing. The service connects you with an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who can review your contract and do the arithmetic with you.
Sources
No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.