CompareTaux

Guides · Mortgage

Your score is only a number. The lender reads everything behind it.

What a Canadian credit file contains, the factors that carry weight, and the moves that improve or damage a score without your noticing.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

A credit score summarizes a file kept by a credit reporting agency. The lender also reads what sits behind it: payments, use of limits, recent applications. Checking your own file does not affect your score, and correcting an error takes time.

The two agencies

Two credit reporting agencies maintain files in Canada. Their data and models differ, so your scores differ too. A lender may pull one, the other, or both, depending on its policies and the type of financing requested.

This difference often surprises people. You check your score in a banking app, find it satisfactory, then discover a lender sees another one. That is no anomaly: each agency receives its information from lenders that do not necessarily report the same things, and each calculates the score in its own way.

What matters is less the exact number than the consistency between the two files. An account missing at one, an outdated address, a balance that has not been updated: these gaps can explain a score difference and deserve checking.

It is therefore useful to review both files, not just one. You do that directly with each agency, following the process it publishes. Do not rely on a single indicator, especially if it comes from a service that shows it for information only and is not the one the lender will use.

What the file contains

A credit file is not just a score. It is a detailed history of your relationship with credit, which the lender can read line by line.

It generally includes:

  • your credit accounts, such as cards, lines of credit, and loans, with their limits and balances;
  • payment history over several years, including any late payments;
  • recent credit applications, meaning checks run by lenders;
  • accounts in collection;
  • public records, such as a bankruptcy, a consumer proposal, or a judgment;
  • identifying information, such as name, address, and declared employer.

It does not generally include your income, your savings, or the value of your property. Those are examined elsewhere in the assessment of an application.

A lender reviewing a financing request therefore reads far more than a number. It looks at the regularity of payments, the level of debt, the presence of recent delinquencies, and how you use the credit available to you. Two people with the same score can thus present very different files.

The factors that weigh most

The agencies do not always publish the detail of their models, but the major factors are known. Payment history and credit utilization dominate.

Payment history measures whether you settle your accounts on time. A recent or repeated late payment weighs more than an old, isolated one.

Utilization compares your balances to your limits. Using a high proportion of your available limits counts against you, even if you pay in full each month, because the snapshot is taken at statement time rather than at payment time. This surprises many people who consider themselves beyond reproach.

Other factors also come into play, with varying weight:

  • the average age of your accounts;
  • the variety of credit types you hold;
  • the number of recent applications;
  • the presence of accounts in collection or public records.

A simple way to remember it: the model tries to learn whether you repay reliably and whether you lean heavily on credit. The habits that answer those two questions are the most useful. No score is built in a week, and no quick strategy is guaranteed.

Credit inquiries

Each time a lender checks your file as part of an application, a record is made. Several applications in quick succession to different lenders can weigh on the score, because they can signal an urgent need for credit.

Two kinds of checks should be distinguished. A check run by a lender, at your request, leaves a visible record. A review of your own file has no effect on your score. You can therefore check your file as often as needed without fear of damaging it.

Models often recognize that a consumer is comparing offers for the same type of loan, such as a mortgage or an auto loan, within a short period. Those applications may be grouped. The precise rules vary by agency and model and are best verified with them.

A few useful habits:

  • group your financing comparisons into a short period;
  • avoid opening several credit accounts at once, for store offers for example;
  • ask a lender whether it runs a full or preliminary check before agreeing;
  • remember that not every application leads to a loan.

The counterintuitive move

Many people think they are doing the right thing by closing an old, lightly used credit card to “tidy up” before applying for financing. That move can have the opposite effect.

Closing an old card cuts your available credit and shortens the average age of your accounts. Utilization rises mechanically, since the same balances are measured against lower limits. The score can fall.

Some people also open several cards to get purchase discounts just before applying for a loan. That adds recent applications and new accounts, which is not favourable.

Before financing, it is therefore generally best to close nothing and open nothing, keep paying on time, and let balances come down naturally. That principle of stability applies to the weeks and months before an application.

This general advice does not replace a review of your situation. There are cases where closing a card is justified, for instance to stop paying an annual fee you no longer want. An authorized person registered with the AMF, or a budget counselling service, can help you assess the likely effect of a move before you make it.

Check and correct

You have the right to obtain your file from each agency and to have an inaccuracy corrected. It is a recognized consumer right, and the agencies publish the process for exercising it.

Do it several months before applying for financing. A correction takes time: the error must be documented, reported to the agency, verified by the lender concerned, and then updated. A wrong file can be costly, because it can influence the rate offered or eligibility for financing.

When reading the file, pay attention to several things:

  • accounts you do not recognize, which may signal fraud or identity theft;
  • wrong balances or limits;
  • late payments recorded in error;
  • closed accounts still shown as open, or the reverse;
  • addresses or employers you never had.

If you suspect identity theft, act quickly: contact the agencies and the lender concerned, and keep a written record of every step. Consumer protection organizations publish useful information on these situations.

A hypothetical scenario

Imagine Julien and Sophie, who plan a purchase within the year. They review their files with both agencies and notice two things: their scores are not identical, and an old phone account still shows as unpaid at one of them.

They contact the agency and the provider, present their proof of payment, and request the correction. They know it may take time and are not alarmed, since they started early.

Meanwhile, Julien had been thinking of closing two old cards. He drops the idea after understanding the possible effect on utilization and average account age. They also decide to pay down their balances before the statement date rather than after, so the “snapshot” is lighter.

A few months later, they meet an authorized person to discuss their project. They arrive with up-to-date files, a clear picture of their debt, and specific questions.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no result. It shows a method: check early, correct what needs correcting, avoid counterproductive moves, and prepare the meeting. The decision to grant financing always rests with the lender.

Mistakes to avoid

Several mistakes come up often around the credit file. Knowing them lets you avoid them without particular effort.

  • Believing there is only one score, when each agency has its own.
  • Relying on a free indicator without checking the actual file.
  • Paying a card in full, but only after the statement date, with a high balance at snapshot time.
  • Closing old accounts just before a financing application.
  • Opening several credit accounts at the same time.
  • Multiplying credit applications without grouping them.
  • Waiting until the eve of an application to check the file.
  • Ignoring an error because it looks minor.
  • Paying a company that promises to “repair” a file in a few days.

That last mistake deserves particular attention. No service can erase accurate information, and offers of this kind are a known source of losses. Correcting an error is done free of charge, with the agency concerned.

An authorized person registered with the AMF can review with you what a lender is likely to read in your file.

Questions to ask

Before submitting a financing application, a short list of questions helps you prepare the meeting and avoid surprises.

  • Which agency, or agencies, does the lender consult?
  • Is the check preliminary or full, and does it leave a record?
  • Which elements of my file are likely to draw attention?
  • Are my files consistent from one agency to the other?
  • Are there errors to correct before I apply?
  • Which moves are best avoided in the coming weeks?
  • How does the lender take my history and my debt into account?
  • What other documents will be requested in addition to the credit file?

These questions are for an authorized person registered with the AMF, who can apply the rules to your situation. They commit you to nothing.

For general information, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada publishes resources on credit, and consumer protection organizations also offer help. CompareTaux shows no rates and makes no decision: the service routes a request to an authorized person.

Frequently asked questions

Why do my scores differ from one agency to the other?

Each agency receives its data from lenders that do not always report the same things, and calculates the score with its own model. A difference is therefore normal. What matters is consistency between the files: a missing account or an error may deserve checking.

Does checking my own file lower my score?

No. Reviewing your own file has no effect on the score. Only checks run by a lender as part of an application leave a record that can weigh, especially if they are numerous and close together.

Should I close my old cards before applying for a loan?

Generally not. Closing a card reduces available credit and shortens average history, which can lower the score. Before financing, it is usually best to close nothing and open nothing. An authorized person can assess your particular case.

How long does it take to correct an error?

It depends on the nature of the error and how quickly the lender and the agency respond. Plan for several weeks, or even months. That is why it is advised to check your file well before a financing application, and to keep a record of every step.

Can a company repair my credit file?

No service can erase accurate information. Correcting an error is done directly with the agency, free of charge. Be wary of offers that promise to “repair” a file quickly for a fee, and consult a consumer protection organization if needed.

Does the score alone decide whether a loan is approved?

No. The lender reads the whole file and weighs it with other elements, such as income, debt, and down payment. The decision is the lender’s. An authorized person registered with the AMF can explain what will be examined.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.