There is no universal amount: an income multiple gives a ballpark, the needs approach is the most defensible, and the result should be revisited as life changes. A person authorised by the AMF can apply these methods to your situation.
Why the amount question is hard
Choosing a life insurance amount means trying to put a number on an event you hope is far off, for people whose circumstances will change before then. There is no single answer: there are methods, each with strengths and blind spots.
The most common trap is to take a figure heard somewhere, a “multiple of salary”, and treat it as a calculation. It is a shortcut. It can start the conversation, but it says nothing about your debts, your assets or how long the need will really last.
This article presents three approaches, recalls the item that is almost always forgotten (latent tax), explains how to account for what is already covered and why the amount must be reviewed. It contains no figures and no recommendation: an authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can apply these methods to your file.
The goal is not a perfect amount, which does not exist, but an amount you can explain: what it is for, who it is for and for how long.
The income multiple approach
Multiplying annual income by a factor gives a ballpark in seconds. It is useful to start a conversation, but the method ignores your actual debts, your existing assets and how long the need lasts.
Why is it so widespread? Because it is simple, needs no documents and is easy to remember. But two people with the same income can have very different needs: one has a large mortgage and young children, the other has paid off nearly everything and has independent children. The same multiple would still produce the same amount.
This shortcut also has a quiet flaw: it does not say what the money is for. Yet that is the central question. An amount whose purpose is unknown is hard to defend, hard to revise, and easy to overestimate or underestimate.
Use it for what it is: a first reference point, to be tested afterwards against a finer method. If someone stops at an income multiple, ask what they assume about your debts, your assets and how long your obligations will last.
The needs approach
This is the most defensible method, because it starts from what the benefit must accomplish. You add up the goals, then subtract what already exists.
On the needs side you will generally find:
- clearing debts: mortgage, line of credit, car loan, card balances;
- replacing income for a defined number of years, while the family adjusts;
- funding education or other commitments already made;
- costs at death: funeral, estate costs, fees;
- particular needs: a dependent relative, a business to protect.
On the resources side you subtract readily available assets, savings, coverage already in place and benefits from public plans. The result is a net need, not a number pulled from a hat.
This method takes more effort, because information has to be gathered. But it has a great advantage: every line can be discussed, adjusted or removed. If a goal changes, you know exactly which piece of the amount moves. That is what makes it easier to revise over time.
The human capital approach
This approach estimates the present value of your future income to retirement. In other words, it asks: what is the value today of everything you would earn if you could keep working?
It suits a young household whose main asset is earning capacity. In that case, debts and savings do not yet reflect the true weight of the potential loss, while the value of future income is considerable.
By construction, it often yields a higher figure than the other two. That is not a flaw in itself, but you should know it: a high amount is not necessarily the appropriate amount. You have to ask whether the family would truly need to replace all that income, over that whole period.
The approach also rests on assumptions (income growth, assumed return on capital, retirement date), which strongly influence the result. Always ask which assumptions were used, in writing, so you can change them and compare two calculations honestly.
In practice, many authorised persons cross two methods and examine the gap to understand what explains it.
Latent tax, the classic omission
At death, certain assets are deemed disposed of: a rental property, a cottage, securities with accrued gains, an RRSP not rolled to a spouse. The resulting tax is payable by the estate, often in cash.
This is the item quick calculations almost always forget. On paper, the value of the estate seems sufficient to cover the needs. In practice, part of that value is locked in an asset that would have to be sold, sometimes at a bad time, to pay the tax.
To spot this risk, take stock of what may have gained in value:
- a property other than the main residence;
- non-registered investments that have grown;
- retirement savings plans of significant value;
- an interest in a business.
The amount of tax depends on tax rules that change and on your precise situation: do not try to calculate it alone from a figure found online. The websites of Revenu Québec and the Canada Revenue Agency explain the principles, and a tax specialist or an authorised person can work through your case.
What is already covered
Before setting an amount, you need to know what already exists. Group coverage through an employer, protection tied to the mortgage, a survivor pension from a public plan: these lower the net need, but they end or change with employment and are not all portable.
Employer coverage is a good example. It is convenient, but it ends if you leave the company or if the plan is modified, often at the moment you are least able to insure yourself elsewhere. Relying on it as your only base means building on ground that is not yours.
Mortgage-linked protection has its own features too: the beneficiary is generally the lender, and the insured amount follows the loan balance. It settles the debt, but not the rest of the needs.
As for benefits from public plans, they depend on your contributions and on the survivors’ situation. Retraite Québec describes the principles.
Make a list of everything that exists, with, for each item: who the beneficiary is, what ends it, and whether it can follow you if your situation changes.
A hypothetical scenario
Picture a person we will call Inès, a salaried worker in a couple, with two young children and a mortgage. She has heard of a “multiple of salary” and wonders whether that figure suits her.
She first decides to list what the benefit should accomplish: clear the mortgage debt, give her partner time to adjust without financial pressure, fund the children’s education and cover costs at death. She then notes what already exists: group coverage tied to her job and a little savings.
She remembers that she also owns a small inherited building that has gained value. Speaking with an authorised person, she learns that estate tax deserves a look. She also sees that her employer coverage would disappear if she changed jobs.
This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: start from goals, subtract what exists, do not forget latent tax, check portability, then have it all validated by a registered person. The final amount depends on each situation.
Mistakes to avoid
A few mistakes come up often when determining an amount. Knowing them lets you avoid them without special effort.
- Sticking to an income multiple without ever checking what it covers.
- Forgetting latent tax on assets that have gained value.
- Counting on employer group coverage as if it were permanent.
- Ignoring the duration of the need: some obligations fade over time, others last a long while.
- Choosing an amount based on what you can afford rather than what you must cover, without knowing what is left uncovered.
- Overlooking a dependent relative or a business.
- Setting the amount once and never returning to it.
None of these mistakes is rare, and none is beyond repair if caught in time. The real cost shows mostly when the contract has to be used: too late to adjust.
A good way to avoid them is to write, in one sentence, what each insured dollar is meant to accomplish. If the sentence is impossible to write, the matching line probably needs to be clarified with an authorised person.
The amount gets revised
A birth, a purchase, a separation, a debt paid off or a job change all alter the calculation. An amount set once and never revisited becomes wrong within a few years.
Many events justify a second look:
- the arrival of a child or the end of their studies;
- buying or selling a property, a refinancing;
- the start or end of a union;
- a job change that alters group coverage;
- creating, selling or growing a business;
- an inheritance, a death in the family, a change in health.
Some of these events increase the need, others reduce it. Do not see the review as a way to buy more: sometimes it shows that coverage has become excessive or poorly suited.
Get into the habit of checking your coverage on a fixed date, for example once a year, and whenever an important event occurs. Keep your documents together, and ask your advisor what each change implies for your existing contracts before modifying any of them.
Questions to ask an authorised person
A meeting is worth preparing. Here are questions that help you understand how an amount is established.
- Which method are you using, and why that one for my situation?
- What assumptions did you make about the duration of the need and my future income?
- Did you account for the tax that may be payable by the estate?
- Which existing coverage did you count, and which could disappear if I change jobs?
- What happens if my obligations shrink or grow?
- How is this amount revised, and when should I come back to it?
- Can you give me the calculation in writing?
Also check the person’s registration in the AMF’s public register.
CompareTaux is a referral service: it displays no premium or recommended amount and makes no automated decision. It routes your request to an authorised person, who can review your file, explain the calculation and answer your questions. You are under no obligation to follow through.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a standard life insurance amount?
No. An income multiple gives a ballpark, but it ignores your debts, assets and how long the need lasts. The needs approach is more precise. An authorised person can apply it to your situation and explain each line to you.
Why is latent tax so often forgotten?
Because it only appears at death: certain assets are then deemed disposed of and the tax is payable by the estate, often in cash. Quick calculations ignore it. A tax specialist or an authorised person can estimate its effect in your case.
Is my group insurance enough?
It lowers the net need, but it generally ends with employment and is not always transferable. Check with your employer what happens if you leave, and ask an authorised person to account for it in the calculation.
When should I review my amount?
At every important event: a birth, a purchase, a separation, a debt paid off, a job change, a business. Also plan a check on a fixed date, for example once a year. An amount never revisited often becomes unsuitable within a few years.
Is a higher amount always safer?
Not necessarily. An amount should match specific goals. Too high, it may cost more than needed; too low, it leaves needs uncovered. What matters is being able to explain what each part of the benefit is for.
Will CompareTaux tell me which amount to choose?
No. CompareTaux displays no premium, recommends no amount and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with a person authorised by the AMF, who can review your situation and present options.
Sources
No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.